I have heard a lot of apology for the human exploitation involved in the resources utilized in modern technology. "We need phones!" everyone says. Certainly you need one for employers or family and friends to reach you. And often there are difficulties for those without smart phones as QR codes and apps are considered normal. But is "need" accurate? In the majority of places, you can obviously live quite comfortably with a dumb phone, maybe even a landline.

Even more troubling to me is something like chocolate or cane sugar. These are, of course, in no way necessities. Yet there is almost total silence. It will be used as a throwaway to criticize a particular company, but there are no calls to boycott the industry as a whole. We debate reparations and wonder how anyone could abide this institution as we actively benefit from it in the most disgustingly greedy and decadent ways.