Barracoon very well may be the most startling book I have ever read. It was in no way what I expected. While there is much I am ignorant of, I did not view myself as having a romanticized and flattened conception of African cultures around the time of European chattel slavery. Yet this book left me completely shocked. The Dahome I was already aware of. Hearing Oluale Kossola mention slaves in his family’s village caught me off guard, although this was of course more the style of slavery common the world over. What made my blood run cold was his nostalgia for and pride in his family’s high status in an authoritarian society with public execution, uncritically sharing a story of a man being beheaded because a leopard he had killed allegedly was missing a whisker, which was superstitiously believed to be a source of a poison, and automatically was viewed as being equal to intention to murder someone.

What do you do with such a story? How did Zora Neale Hurston react, I wondered. This meandering tangent was a total non-sequitur, in no way prompted by her questions. If you read the Wikipedia, you can see one response: erasure. The summary stating “Barracoon gives Lewis’ perspective showing how he was flourishing in a thriving society before being captured and relocated” is so ghoulish to almost be laughable. The book was finally released in 2018, after decades of no publisher willing to release complex and unvarnished reality. A former slave finally had the opportunity to tell his story. But who is really listening?