There were a lot of things that stood out to me yesterday, reading the parshah and the haftarot. It must be because I just finished Adam, Eve, and the Serpent, but it was very interesting revisiting the Garden of Eden narrative with Augustine and Julian's disagreement in mind. On the one hand, I think the intent of the biblical authors was to use this as an origin myth. Why must we labor and die? Why are women almost universally oppressed by men, and suffer pain in childbirth, and yet largely still love men? Obviously these are timeless questions, and the narrative of being cast out of Eden gives an answer.
On a religious level, I find Julian's argument very very compelling. Narratively, why would Eve and Adam eating from the Tree of Knowledge cause sweat, thorns, and thistles to exist? Why would female mammals also have to suffer from live birth? Augustine largely created the idea of the "Fall" as is now deeply embedded in Western culture. He thought that humanity had no free will (with sexuality as his central piece of evidence) at all due to this sin being carried hereditarily in all human beings and that we were cursed to die because of it. Julian viewed this as a deeply twisted understanding of the Jewish bible and later Christian ideology. In his view, death was always part of the plan, and in fact serves as a gift in the sense that it means all our suffering in life is limited. We are not doomed, and in fact are blessed with the freedom of choice. Eve and Adam are in some ways dual Prometheuses.
I also thought it was interesting that there is no mention of the Tree of Life until the pair have eaten from the Tree of Knowledge. Where was it? Were they allowed to eat from it before? There is of course a precedent for mythical heroes seeking immortality and having it taken away from them. But Adam and Eve knew nothing of the tree until they were already on their way out! I would argue that they were "intended" to be mortal even if they had never eaten from the Tree of Knowledge. They were already established as a pair and told to reproduce. Sex is part of the "goodness" of creation! We live, we have children, we die, and it repeats.
Even after leaving the Garden, humans live for hundreds of years, and it is only in these post-Adam and Eve generations that God decides to nerf their lifespans and eventually start almost from scratch. You definitely get the sense that there is more history to these characters than the Bible recounts. (I was pretty interested in the Nephilim as a kid, due to the midrash Many Waters by Madeline L'engle, haha. The college and grad school equivalent of this would be the Book of Enoch, I guess.) Lamech's sudden boast to his wives, apparently known as the Song of the Sword, really stood out. He just out of nowhere tells them he killed a kid? It certainly seems like an old poem, and I guess the consensus is that it has been repurposed as a legitimate point of cultural pride to a critique of pre-Israelite life. I have so many questions about this period! If only I could use a time machine as well!